Overview

When the time comes for a group to make a decision on whether to accept a prospective member, the choice can sometimes be confusing and challenging.  The group gets only one meeting during which to evaluate a prospective member, but once they accept a member, that person is presumed to be permanent fixture in the group.  This document is designed to simplify the decision-making process.

A successful fit between a member and their group depends on the degree to which the member can:  (1) contribute to the group; and (2) get value from the group.  Members contribute value through their experience, skills, personality, and the quality of issues that they bring to the group.  The group is responsible for evaluating what the member can contribute.  The prospective member, on the other hand, is also sizing up what they can gain from the group.  They are responsible for figuring out their ability to benefit from what the group has to offer.  Both sides need to say yes for a match to happen.

Determining Fit

Determining fit is inevitably a subjective and fuzzy process.  Above all, members need to follow their gut when deciding whether to accept a member.  There are some questions, however, that can help with the decision making process:

  1. Is the member facing challenges similar to those faced by others in the group? The answer to this question is largely related to the stage of business. A solopreneur who is launching a new consulting practice will almost certainly face challenges different from a CEO who is about to hire their 20th employee. For the sake of simplicity, Netcito categorizes companies into three categories: (1) early (1-4 employees); (2) middle (5-25 employees); and (3) advanced (more than 25 employees). Mid-stage businesses can match with early and advanced groups, but it’s generally not a good idea to combine early and advanced companies.
  2. Is the prospect a wildcard? There are a couple of instances in which stage of business shouldn’t be a factor in determining membership: (1) coaches can match with virtually any group because their skillset usually enables them to contribute value at any stage of business; and (2) the highest stage reached over the course of someone’s career is more important than the stage of their current project. In the latter case, an entrepreneur who started and/or sold a prior company with 20 employees should be treated as an advanced entrepreneur.
  3. Is there an obvious miss with chemistry? Despite the fact that we interview candidates prior to nominating them to a group, they sometimes show up differently in the course of a longer meeting. Red flags, which can be a legitimate basis for passing on a new member nomination, can include:
    1. Monopolizing too much airtime
    2. Staying in their shell and doesn’t make any substantive contributions
    3. Being closed to feedback

When to Pass

The decision to accept a member is more about identifying an obvious miss for membership than finding an ideal fit.  Over time, the vast majority of nominees end up being valuable contributors to Netcito groups.  Most entrepreneurs share baseline values, integrity, and ambition that make it easy for them to fit together, especially by the time that they make it through the interview process prior to being nominated.

Groups should think seriously about passing when there is an obvious miss in terms of company stage or chemistry.  It goes without saying that groups should be willing to pass on a member when there is any evidence of dishonesty or lack of integrity.

Process During the Meeting

Groups decide whether to accept a member at the end of the prospective member’s first meeting.  Following the completion of group business, the group excuses the prospective member from the room, then conducts a discussion and vote on whether to accept the member.

It can be tempting to skip the step of a formal discussion and vote when accepting a new member.  Asking a prospective member to leave the room can feel overly formal and uncomfortable.  We strongly recommend, however, against taking shortcuts.  The recusal, discussion, and vote serve several important purposes:

Important: After the Meeting

After making a decision, We encourage you to immediately notify a member if they are accepted. If the group decides to pass, you can either let the member know directly or share the decision with Netcito, who will share the decision and explain it in terms that will minimize offense and hurt feelings with the prospect.

Whatever the group decides, please act promptly to communicate the decision to Netcito.  Members take a personal risk when they submit an application.  We want to honor their initiative by responding promptly.