Purpose
- When a new member joins a group, the Chair plays an important role in managing the process. Adding a new member alters group dynamics, introducing a new ingredient that impacts existing group members. Among other things, the presence of a new person can influence the willingness of current members to share their experiences or participate and, ultimately, the quality of discussion.
- For a new member, the experience of arriving in a new group can be intimidating. Good preparation for introducing new members can go a long way toward helping them feel welcome.
- Incorporating a new member into a group requires two things: (1) establishing the legitimacy of the new member to be in the group; and (2) creating opportunities for the group to get to know the new member as a whole person.
- As a business matter, the group needs to decide whether or not to accept a new member.
Highlights
- Welcome: when the new member arrives at the meeting, make an effort to introduce them to your fellow members individually.
- Group Introductions: upon opening the meeting, after the minute of silence, acknowledge the new member’s attendance and ask for each current member to introduce themselves by saying who they are and what they do in 30 seconds (model by going first yourself).
- New Member Introduction: ask the new member to introduce themselves in 2 minutes or less. Following their introduction, have members ask 2-3 ‘get to know you’ questions provided in your agenda or chair packet. These questions should include the required one about confidentiality.
- If a member chooses to present an issue, have them present 2nd or 3rd in the “batting order.” That’s far enough in for the prospect to get a sense of how the group operates, but early enough so that they don’t get squeezed for time before the end of the meeting.
- Vote: excuse the member 5 minutes early and ask the group to vote on inviting the prospective member to join the circle. If the vote is unanimous, reach out to the member (via phone or email) to let them know and celebrate the decision. If the vote isn’t unanimous, discuss as a group ‘ideal member criteria’ and why this member doesn’t fit. Report the decision in the meeting notes or directly to Netcito.
Preparing
- Two days prior to the meeting, email or call the new member to introduce yourself, briefly explain how the meeting works, and help them identify an issue.
- If needed, help them sharpen their issue.
- Explain that presenting an issue is optional, and not every member presents an issue at every meeting. It depends on what other members bring to the table.
During the Meeting
- Opening
- If the new member hasn’t already met the rest of the group, introduce them by name during the opening segment of the meeting.
- Direct current members to the biography for the new member, which is included with the meeting agenda.
- Remind the new member that they’ll be excused early so that the group can make a decision about their membership at the end of the meeting.
- Initial Introduction (Following the minute of silence) - no longer than 5 minutes
- You can think about a Netcito meeting as a swimming pool. The meeting begins at the shallow end and gradually gets deeper as the meeting progresses. As you introduce the new member, follow a similar process that gradually deepens their interaction with the group.
- Before asking for check-ins from the rest of the group, it helps to provide some quick introductions:
- Introduce the group to the member by asking current members to quickly share their name and business. This should take about 15-30 seconds per member. Model by going first yourself.
- Introduce the current member to the group through some basic, “get to know you” questions:
- Who are you?
- Where are you from?
- What do you do?
- Ask the member the required question about confidentiality
- If time permits, ask the prospective member some additional questions:
- Can you tell us about a recent win? (this helps to establish the right of the member to be in the group)
- What’s one thing that makes you unique?
- Give one or more members the option of asking more probing new member questions that are included with the agenda (see New Member Interview Guide). This provides an opportunity to reveal more about the new member and squeeze in a few laughs.
- Issue Presentation - 20-30 minutes
- Ideally, a prospective member should present in the second spot in the “batting order.” That’s far enough in for the prospect to get a sense of how the group operates, but early enough so that they don’t get squeezed for time before the end of the meeting.
- Realize that because prospective members are new to the Netcito process, it may take longer to work through their issues.
- Business
- After concluding the regular business of the meeting, excuse the prospect so that the group can make a decision on whether to accept them as a full member.
- While excusing a prospective member sounds like it could be an awkward moment, it does not need to be in practice. The Chair can lead the process by thanking the member for attending the meeting and explaining that this is a standard practice for all Netcito groups.
- Some guidelines on discussing and voting on prospective members:
- All votes to accept a permanent member need to be unanimous. If there is a single objection, the member will not be accepted. This is based on a principle of fairness. Every member needs to be comfortable about including someone new in the group. Members are entitled to their own perspective even if they are in the minority.
- Groups sometimes struggle with consensus because of questions about whether a member is qualified. In these cases, it can help to shift the focus of the discussion toward reaching consensus about the ideal and minimum qualifications for joining the group. Once a group has clarity about ideal and minimum qualifications, the decision about acceptance can become easier. Incorporate any decisions about qualifications into the meeting minutes.
- Groups sometimes also struggle with membership decisions because of diversity issues. Once again, it can help to shift the focus from the prospective member to the question of the ideal diversity mix for the group. Consensus on group size is also an important factor to consider. Netcito groups can operate optimally with as many as 15 members, and the quality of group discussion grows as the group gets bigger to reach its maximum size. If the group can reach consensus about overall size and diversity in its composition, the decision about whether to accept a prospective member becomes easier. Incorporate any decisions about diversity into meeting minutes.