Prefer to listen instead of read? Here’s a podcast of this article:

The Netcito Approach_ QOREA Feedback.wav


When we first started Netcito, we aimed to keep things simple, offering little guidance on how members should provide feedback. This approach gave ample room for advice-giving, but it quickly became clear that it wasn’t working. Several groups struggled or fell apart due to issues directly tied to advice-giving dynamics. One member described the experience as “bad consulting”—presenting an issue only to be met with 5-10 underqualified and underinformed opinions. Instead of fostering connection and growth, advice-giving often led to frustration, disengagement, and even conflict within the group.

Here's some of what we learned:

  1. It's Nearly Impossible to Fully Grasp the Dimensions of Someone Else's Challenge

    To give truly effective advice, you would need to understand not only the presenter’s perspective but also the circumstances and viewpoints of everyone else involved in the situation. Often, even the presenter doesn’t fully understand these dynamics. It's virtually impossible to gain this level of insight without a Vulcan Mind Meld. Even with the benefit of telepathy, advice still usually misses the mark.

  2. The Advice-Giver Can Be Wrong

    Even with the best intentions, advice-givers often lack the complete context to offer the right solution. Advice that feels logical or obvious to the giver can be off-target, impractical, or even harmful for the person receiving it.

  3. Advice Creates an Obligation

    Receiving advice often carries an unspoken pressure to follow it, even when it doesn’t align with the recipient’s needs, values, or instincts. This dynamic can lead to frustration or resentment with both the advice-giver and receiver. We had one group ask to expel a member because that person wasn't taking their advice. They didn't even pause to consider that their advice might be off target.

  4. It Shifts Focus Away from the Presenter

    When groups get into advice-giving mode, the discussion often centers on the advice-giver’s thoughts and experiences rather than the presenter’s unique challenge. This can create a sense of group momentum that steamrolls the presenter, leaving them unheard and disconnecting the group from the true essence of the issue.

  5. It Gives a Fish Instead of Teaching to Fish

    Even if advice happens to be spot-on (a rare occurrence), it simply hands over a solution rather than helping the presenter develop the tools and confidence to navigate their challenge independently. The real growth comes from learning how to solve problems, not from adopting someone else’s solution.

  6. Only the Presenter Can Navigate Their Challenge

    Ultimately, the person facing the challenge is the only one who truly understands the nuances of their situation. They are the only one capable of finding the right path forward, and the group’s role is to support their growth—not to prescribe.

By focusing on asking insightful questions, sharing relevant experiences, and providing resources or observations, peer forums empower presenters to develop their own clarity and confidence. This approach keeps the conversation centered on the presenter’s needs while fostering a collaborative and respectful environment where everyone learns and grows together.

The Netcito Approach to Feedback: QOREA

At Netcito, we’ve developed a structured approach to providing feedback, designed to empower the presenter and support their growth. We use the acronym QOREA: